Opinions of Value

Your source for appraisal news and trends

Menu
  • Home
  • AI Resources
  • Education
  • Publications
  • Professional Practice
  • News
  • Advocacy
  • About Us
You are here: Home / appraisal regulation / Appraisal Threshold Debate a Sign of Bigger Problems

Appraisal Threshold Debate a Sign of Bigger Problems

October 19, 2015 by Appraisal Institute Staff

In recent remarks to a community banking conference, St. Louis Federal Reserve President James Bullard joined the chorus of voices within the banking sector suggesting one way to ease the regulatory burden of banks would be to raise the threshold for when an appraisal is required.

“Inflation adjustment alone suggests that the threshold in 2015 should be higher,” Bullard explained. “We estimate the number of required appraisals would decline significantly.” The threshold currently stands at $250,000 transaction value for any real estate and $1 million for owner-occupied commercial real estate loans, but some proposals would double the threshold, at least for real estate.

changing_rules

As the federal banking agencies get deeper into the Economic Growth and Regulatory Paperwork Reduction Act process, the Appraisal Institute has been the singular voice cautioning against increasing the threshold, pointing out problems identified in bank failures relating to appraisal management by banks, and at the same time how many banks have learned from past mistakes and embraced the appraisal process by hiring qualified appraisers to manage valuation risk management activities. These operations are helping banks make better informed real estate lending decisions.

Some community banks have made raising the appraisal threshold a big priority, testifying in Congress, as well as during EGRPRA field hearings advancing the proposed increase. The next EGRPRA hearing takes place Oct. 19 at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, and we expect the issue of raising the appraisal threshold to be a hot topic.

Still, the issue runs much deeper than the issues that appear on the surface. Some banks are looking to avoid a fundamental risk management process in large sectors of the real estate market, not only because of an inability to find qualified appraisers, or the cost of the appraisal itself but because of the increased burdens surrounding the appraisal and the appraisal license. Like appraisal service providers, institutionally employed appraisers face a myriad of compliance obligations in maintaining their licenses to prepare appraisals and appraisal reviews, and even obtain licenses in some cases. This realm has become extremely complicated and convoluted for banks from a practice, licensing and management standpoint.

All of these calls for avoidance should tell us something about our regulatory structure, pointing strongly to a need for modernization. Regulatory relief should be advanced not just for banks, but for valuation professionals who are progressively boxed into a corner in the face of rules and regulatory obligations. The current push to opt out of the appraisal process is but one more indication of the need for a fresh look at the appraisal regulatory structure and identifying more efficient and effective systems and operations.

Filed Under: appraisal regulation, appraisal threshold

Latest Posts

  • Appraisal Institute Annual Conference Kicks Off Next Week July 29, 2022
  • Online Registration Closes Soon for 2022 Annual Conference June 24, 2022
  • Annual Conference Registration Now Open May 27, 2022
  • Keynote Speaker Announced for 2022 Annual Conference April 29, 2022
  • A Look Inside AI Education: Desktop Appraisals (Bifurcated, Hybrid) and Evaluations Seminar Preview April 21, 2022
  • PAVE Action Plan Released, AI Provided Input March 25, 2022
  • 4 Innovative Commercial Building Features That Could Prove Difficult to Appraise March 15, 2022
  • Share Your Expertise at this Year’s Appraisal Institute Annual Conference February 25, 2022
  • Technology Can Aid, Not Replace, Appraisers February 17, 2022
  • Fair Housing Report on TAF Released, PAVE Report Expected Next January 28, 2022

Posts by topic

  • 2014 Presidents message (5)
  • 2015 President's Messages (12)
  • 2016 President's Messages (8)
  • 2017 President's Messages (13)
  • 2018 Annual Conference (5)
  • 2018 Appraisal Institute President's Messages (3)
  • 2018 President's Messages (9)
  • 2019 Annual Conference (8)
  • 2019 President's Messages (12)
  • 2020 Appraisal Institute President's Messages (8)
  • 2020 President's Messages (5)
  • 2021 President's Message (8)
  • AI Connect (5)
  • AMS (2)
  • appraisal bias (1)
  • appraisal careers (17)
  • Appraisal Insstitute designatons (2)
  • Appraisal Institute (220)
  • Appraisal Institute Annual Meeting (8)
  • Appraisal Institute Annual Meeting (4)
  • Appraisal Institute blog (10)
  • Appraisal Institute Body of Knowledge (3)
  • Appraisal Institute chapters (1)
  • Appraisal Institute designation (5)
  • Appraisal Institute Designations (8)
  • Appraisal Institute Education (2)
  • Appraisal Institute Green Addendum (2)
  • Appraisal Institute media coverage (6)
  • Appraisal Institute volunteer opportunities (3)
  • appraisal legislation (4)
  • appraisal myths (3)
  • appraisal regulation (8)
  • appraisal threshold (5)
  • appraisal thresholds (4)
  • appraisal waivers (1)
  • appraiser diversity (1)
  • appraiser trainee (1)
  • Appraisers (9)
  • Arbitration (2)
  • arbitrator (1)
  • association management system (1)
  • automated valuation models (1)
  • AVM (1)
  • Bifurcated (1)
  • Bifurcated Appraisal (2)
  • big-box properties (1)
  • Call for proposals (1)
  • Candidate for Designation (3)
  • Candidate for Designation (3)
  • challenging appraisals (1)
  • co-op appraisals (1)
  • condo appraisals (1)
  • conservation easement appraisals (1)
  • conservation easements (1)
  • consumer appraisal information (11)
  • coronavirus appraisals (1)
  • designations (3)
  • desktop appraisals (2)
  • Diminution valuation (1)
  • exterior appraisals (1)
  • FHA appraisals (1)
  • FHA Handbook 4000.1 (1)
  • green valuation (9)
  • HERS Index (1)
  • HERS rating (1)
  • Highest and best use (2)
  • home appraisals (7)
  • home inspections (3)
  • Home Renovations (2)
  • Home Winterization Tips (2)
  • Hybrid Appraisal (1)
  • International outreach (1)
  • International Valuation Conference (5)
  • landscaping and appraisal (2)
  • landscaping and property values (2)
  • Main (10)
  • market analysis (3)
  • multifamily appraisals (1)
  • office building appraisals (1)
  • office property appraisals (1)
  • oil spills (1)
  • overhead transmission lines (1)
  • property tax appeals (3)
  • PUD appraisals (1)
  • relocation (1)
  • Residential Appraisal (1)
  • residential appraisals (8)
  • residential appraisers (4)
  • RMAT (1)
  • rural property (3)
  • social media for appraisers (2)
  • solar (1)
  • SRA designation (1)
  • TAF (1)
  • taxes (1)
  • technology and valuation (2)
  • testimony (2)
  • The Appraisal Foundation (1)
  • The Appraisal Institute (105)
    • 2022 Presidents Messages (3)
    • Appraisal Institute Review Designations (1)
  • The Appraisal Journal (2)
  • timeshare appraisals (1)
  • transportation (1)
  • Trial preparation (1)
  • USPAP (2)
  • valuation careers (10)
  • volunteer (1)
  • Volunteers of Distinction (8)

RSS AI News

  • Hybrid Appraisals Can Offer New Opportunities for Appraisers: The Appraisal Journal August 11, 2022
  • Rapid Growth and Influx of New Residents Pushes Austin Affordability to the Limit: Valuation Magazine July 26, 2022
  • New Appraisal Institute Book Shares Advice for Appraisers in Real Estate Arbitration July 7, 2022

RSS Industry News

  • US Needs 4 Million More Apartments by 2035, Research Shows August 3, 2022
  • Federal Reserve Planning More Rate Increases to Curb Inflation August 3, 2022
  • Economy is Slowing, Housing Starts and Home Sales Both Decline, Data Reveals August 3, 2022

Follow us

icon_youtubeicon_linkedinicon_twittericon_rssicon_facebook

About this blog

Opinions of Value provides the appraiser perspective on developments in the valuation profession, insight on legislative and regulatory issues and outlook on industry trends.
Terms of Use | Disclaimer | Guest Blogger Guidelines

Dotcomm Award

Copyright © 2022 · Genesis Child on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in